DERFFLINGER написал(а):Да уж, очень интересная позиция. Я так понял, сам фильм взят с Супербитовского релиза Р1, а допы - с Deluxe Edition того же Р1?
это издание считается эталонным - самая лучшая в мире картинка + звук + куча допов + СД саунтрек
DVD review at AVPlay.com
http://avplay.avforums.com/index.php?showreview=5243
The picture is reference quality and the DTS soundtrack is downright frightening. This R3 edition IS the definitive version of the movie and features some stunning extras as well as a free CD soundtrack for the movie.
Highly, highly recommended.
Overall score : 10 of 10
DVD Comparison:
Columbia (Single Disc) - Region 1 - NTSC vs. Columbia (Special Ed. 3-Disc) - Region 1 - NTSC vs. Columbia
(Superbit SE 3-disc) - Region 3 - NTSC
http://www.dvdbeaver.com/film/DVDCompar … wkdown.htm
The bitrate peaks and valleys indicate that there is not a lot of difference between these DVDs. The color balance, image quality and framing are all negligibly exact. The VOB file dates for disc 2 and disc 3 are the same for the US R1 SE and the Korean SB SE 03/24/03 disc 2 03/06/03 disc 3 and the discs are region 1,3,4. The SE and the SB look to be the exact same transfer to me - probably the same DVD (both NTSC with only the Region coding being adjusted). The Korean disc offers a superior audio option with the DTS as well as the 5.1, but the SE has a commentary with the main feature (probably the only decrease difference in bitrate along with the offered DUBs). So, if you want the commentary - get the SE Region 1- if you want DTS get the Korean - and if you only want the film, you won't be disappointed with the Region 1 Single Disc
version for image.
Report Card:
Image: R3 Superbit / R1 Special Edition (tie)
Sound: R3 Superbit
Extras: R1 Special Edition
Menu: R1 Special Edition
и так твердят все обзоры по всему миру!!!!! если нравится этот фильм, наверное лучше релиза нет!!!
Отредактировано AlexF (2007-02-27 23:03:44)